❄ Winter special: 40% off spring & summer bookings — code KP40-WINTER27
Kanan Painting · Ontario & QuebecCall (437) 238-9585

Painting vs. Replacing Kitchen Cabinets — the Honest Comparison

New cabinets, or a new finish on the ones you already own? The right answer depends on your boxes and your layout — not on a sales pitch. Here is how the two options honestly compare on cost, timeline, disruption and durability, and the short checklist that decides it.

Kitchen cabinet painting from $1,399

Call (437) 238-9585 Get a free estimate
Kitchen cabinets before painting — dark wood cabinets before refinishing
Before — dark wood cabinets
Kitchen cabinets after painting — clean white refinished cabinets by Kanan Painting
After — the same kitchen, refinished in white

The same Kanan Painting kitchen, before and after cabinet refinishing

The short answer

If your cabinet boxes are solid and your kitchen layout works, paint them. Cabinet painting with Kanan Painting starts from $1,399 for a standard kitchen, takes days instead of weeks, and leaves your counters, appliances and layout untouched — only the colour and finish change. For most kitchens we inspect, it is the honest recommendation.

Replace the cabinets when the boxes themselves are the problem — water damage, swollen or broken construction — or when you are changing the layout. Replacement is not a bigger version of the same job: it is a renovation, with demolition, new cabinetry, counters and several trades, and a total that typically runs several times the cost of refinishing. This guide compares the two side by side, explains what painting can and cannot fix, and ends with a short checklist to decide which kitchen yours is. We use Sherwin-Williams® and Benjamin Moore® paints.

Side by side: painting vs. replacing

Every row below is a real difference between the two projects — including the rows where replacing wins. A painter who only shows you the flattering rows is selling, not advising.

Painting your cabinetsReplacing your cabinets
CostFrom $1,399 for a standard kitchen, confirmed in a free written estimate. One trade, one price — no demolition, no new materials to buy.No single starting price. New cabinetry is typically the largest line, joined by demolition and disposal, counters, and plumbing and electrical work — the total typically runs several times the cost of refinishing.
TimelineAbout 3–5 working days, plus curing time before heavy use.Typically weeks — demolition, cabinet delivery lead time, fitting, then counter templating and installation once the boxes are in.
Kitchen out of serviceLargely usable throughout: doors are sprayed off-site, and the counters, sink and appliances stay in place.Out of service from demolition until the new counters are installed and the plumbing is reconnected.
DisruptionOne trade in the house, no demolition, minimal dust — the boxes are masked and finished in place.Demolition noise and debris, then a sequence of trades: cabinet installers, counter fabricators, a plumber and an electrician.
DurabilityA cabinet-grade sprayed enamel over your existing solid boxes. Wear at high-touch points can be recoated later without replacing anything; eligible work carries a written 15-year workmanship warranty.New boxes, doors and hardware with a factory finish. Longevity depends heavily on the cabinet quality tier you buy — the cheapest new cabinets are not automatically an upgrade on solid old ones.
What changesColour and finish — and hardware too, if you choose new handles. Layout, counters and appliances stay.Everything can change: layout, storage configuration, doors, counters, and often the sink and appliances around them.
The right choice whenThe boxes are solid and dry, the layout works, and it is the finish that dates the kitchen.The boxes are damaged, the layout genuinely fails, or a full kitchen renovation is already underway.

The first step costs nothing either way: a free written estimate at your Ontario home, where we inspect the boxes before recommending anything. Winter reservations for April–October work are 40% off with code KP40-WINTER27.

What the painting option actually involves

Painting is not a coat of wall paint brushed over doors. Done properly, it is a refinishing process:

  1. Inspection and written estimate. We check the box condition, the cabinet material and the door count — and confirm painting is the right option before quoting it.
  2. Removal and preparation. Doors and drawer fronts come off and are labelled; every surface is degreased, sanded, and repaired where chips and worn edges need it.
  3. Bonding primer. A high-adhesion primer matched to your cabinet material seals the old finish so the new colour holds and does not show through.
  4. Sprayed finish, two coats. Doors and drawers are sprayed flat off-site for a smooth, factory-style finish; the boxes are masked and finished in place.
  5. Curing and reinstallation. Once the finish has hardened, doors are rehung and aligned, and hardware is refitted — or replaced, if new handles were written into your estimate.

The full breakdown — including what moves the price and how curing works — is on our kitchen cabinet painting service page and in the cabinet painting cost guide.

What painting can't fix

This is the section that decides the question, so it comes before the sales pitch: a new finish sits on top of your existing cabinets, and it cannot repair what is underneath it.

Water damage. Swollen, soft or rotted boxes — the sink cabinet is the usual case — cannot hold a finish or their own hinges. That is a replacement conversation.
Broken construction. Cracked door frames, loose joinery and collapsed drawer boxes are carpentry failures, not finish failures. Paint does not rebuild them.
Failing thermofoil. Film that is peeling or bubbling across most doors has lost its bond with the door beneath it, and coating over it traps the failure. A door or two can often be dealt with; doors failing everywhere point to replacement.
A layout that doesn't work. Too little storage, a work triangle that fights you, an island you keep walking around — painting changes none of it. If the layout is the problem, the layout is the project.
Everything that isn't cabinets. Worn counters, damaged flooring and dated appliances are separate scopes with separate trades. A cabinet refresh makes them easier to live with; it does not renew them.
Doors beyond their style. Painting changes colour, not profile. If you want a different door style — flat panels instead of raised, for example — that is new doors, through refacing or replacement, not refinishing.

We check for each of these during the free estimate, before any price is discussed. If replacement is the right answer for your kitchen, we will say so rather than sell you a finish that cannot last — paint over damage we found would fail, and it would fail with our name on it.

White shaker kitchen cabinets with marble-look counters after painting
A recent Kanan Painting cabinet project

The decision checklist: six questions

Answer these honestly about your kitchen — the pattern of answers decides the question better than any price comparison.

  1. Are the boxes solid and dry — especially under the sink? Solid boxes are what painting stands on.
  2. Does the layout work for how you actually cook? If the layout works, replacement buys you the same kitchen at renovation cost.
  3. Are the doors and drawer fronts structurally sound — hinges firm, joints tight, drawers running true?
  4. Is it mainly the colour and finish that date the kitchen? A dated colour on sound cabinets is exactly what refinishing exists for.
  5. Do you need the kitchen back in days rather than weeks? Painting keeps the kitchen largely usable; replacement closes it.
  6. Is your budget a refinish budget rather than a renovation budget? From $1,399 versus a multi-trade renovation total several times higher.

Mostly yes: paint — your kitchen is the standard case this service is built for. No on question 1 or 3: the cabinets themselves are failing, and replacement (or at least new doors) belongs in the conversation. No on question 2: you do not have a cabinet-finish problem at all — you have a renovation, and it should be planned as one.

The math, honestly: one anchor, no invented figures

Our painting price is published: from $1,399 for a standard kitchen, with the exact scope — door and drawer count, colour change, hardware — confirmed in a free written estimate. That figure is the whole cabinet scope. There is no demolition bill, cabinet order or counter invoice standing behind it.

Replacement has no equivalent published number, and this guide will not invent one. What can be listed honestly is what a replacement project is made of: demolition and disposal of the old kitchen; new boxes, doors and hardware — typically the largest single line; new counters, because existing counters rarely survive removal intact; plumbing and electrical adjustments; and the patching of floors and walls the old layout leaves behind. Each line is priced by a different supplier or trade, which is why the finished total typically runs several times the cost of refinishing the cabinets you already own.

The middle path is refacing — new door fronts over your existing boxes. It changes the door style as well as the colour, and it is priced between painting and full replacement. Refacing is a separate service from painting: if it is the right answer for your kitchen, we will say so at the estimate and point you the right way.

Related guides and services

Cabinet painting vs. replacing, answered

Is painting my cabinets worth it, or should I replace them?

Painting is worth it when the cabinet boxes are solid and the layout works — you get a new colour and finish for a project that starts from $1,399, instead of a renovation. Replacing is worth it when the boxes themselves are damaged or you are changing the layout. The deciding question is the condition of the boxes, not the colour of the doors.

How much cheaper is painting cabinets than replacing them?

Cabinet painting with Kanan Painting starts from $1,399 for a standard kitchen, confirmed in a free written estimate. Replacement has no comparable starting price: new cabinetry is only one of its costs, alongside demolition and disposal, counters, and plumbing and electrical adjustments, and the total typically runs several times the cost of refinishing. Anyone who gives you a single replacement figure without measuring your kitchen is guessing.

How long will my kitchen be out of service with each option?

With painting, about 3–5 working days across removal, preparation, spraying and reinstallation, plus curing time before heavy use — and the kitchen stays largely usable through most of it, because doors are sprayed off-site and the counters and appliances stay in place. With replacement, the kitchen is out of service from demolition until the new counters are installed and the plumbing is reconnected — typically weeks.

Will a painted finish last as long as new cabinets?

They are different purchases: new cabinets give you new boxes and hardware with a factory finish, while painting gives your existing solid boxes a new cabinet-grade sprayed finish. A properly prepared enamel finish is hard-wearing, and wear at high-touch points can be recoated later without replacing the cabinets. Eligible completed cabinet work includes our written 15-year workmanship warranty.

What problems can cabinet painting not fix?

Painting cannot repair water-swollen or rotted boxes (the sink cabinet is the usual case), broken door joinery or drawer boxes, thermofoil film that is peeling away across most doors, or a layout that does not work for how you cook. We check for all of these during the free estimate and tell you plainly when replacement — not painting — is the right spend.

Can I change my cabinet colour completely, or only refresh the same colour?

Both. A complete colour change — dark wood to white is the most common — is a standard scope: the old finish is degreased, sanded and sealed with a bonding primer before the new colour is sprayed, so the previous colour does not show through. Two-tone designs, such as a different colour on the island, are also part of a normal estimate.

Get your free kitchen cabinet painting estimate

Tell us about your kitchen and send the form your way: text message, WhatsApp or email. It lands directly with us at (437) 238-9585 — and your written estimate is free. Still deciding between painting and replacing? Send photos of the boxes and doors with your message: the estimate starts with an honest inspection, and we will tell you which option your kitchen actually needs.

Free written estimate — no obligation.

Please add your name and phone number so we can reply to your estimate request.
Choose photos here and the send buttons deliver them to us with your request — no need to attach them again in the chat. Max 5 photos, 10 MB each.

Request your free cabinet painting quote

5.0★ on Google (64 reviews) · 15-year workmanship warranty · WSIB covered & insured · Since 2017 · 3,200+ projects

Call (437) 238-9585 WhatsApp us